We own a 48 unit in the inner city of San Antonio and as such folks who have criminal backgrounds are very common.
I find that tenants who are given an opportunity or call it a second chance are much more loyal than a regular walk in applicant. So I have always offered to felons. Early on, I got to know our local police contact, in our town they are called Safe Officers and in working with them, I would allow or not allow a person based on the applicants criminal record. I do not take at all:
Carrying concealed weapons charges
Selling drugs in the past 4 years
using in the past 2 years
any gang involvement
prostitution last 4 years.
any sexual crime is a big no no.
Violence is a tough one, if the fight is family maybe, there is no clear cut answer. any violence to public is a big no no.
we get a lot of violence within family, and this is tough. I am currently taking a applicant who has violence against other family members, but in researching it, I am ok with that. I talk to their parol officer or other agent official if I have any questions.
I once took a tenant who had committed murder about 20 years ago, and he was having problems finding an apartment, he was very nice so no issue with him.
I love white collar crime, check fraud, driving while drunk, (I have a tenant that left me and is serving one year in jail for drunk driving and I will take him back next month)
I tell folks to tell me everything and one time I had a guy with a 20 page rap sheet, it was crazy but I took him and it worked great. If they do not tell me everything then I skip them. I want honesty.
I give them a 3 month lease and watch them closely. I do get a deposit
They tent to be very loyal and stay for a long time.
I find that I build a reputation of someone who gives a second chance but only if the applicant tells me everything, I make it very clear, that I have a short fuse, any screw ups and they are out.
My last two years I have averaged a 3.5% vacancy rate and my collections are higher than most in my area. 75% of my tenants have been here at least three years.
We have cameras on the property so I see everything and at all hours of the day and night, causes folks to behave at night.
taking criminal is not for the weak at heart, but it works really well for me. My best tenants tend to come with baggage so when something breaks here on the property I am not screamed at by a tenant.
hope it helps
Sam