While I understand that usually the Management Company provides the rules on vendor selection and sets up the bid process, for those who manage smaller communities, this may not be a possibility. For someone with 45 units, this person may BE the company.
When the economy recently went into a downward spiral, I know there were a huge number of layoffs. It seemed, for me anyway, everyone and his brother, uncle, cousin and grandmother came out or contacted apartment communities to get some work. I heard a lot of, "Well, before I worked at the GM Plant, I used to build fences with my father." Or, "Since I got laid off I've been drywalling friends' basements and I can lay tile, etc." Or, "Yes, I painted my house and then I went over to my friend's house and painted his."
It seemed easier to make sure each person who wanted to become a Vendor for me understood he would need liability insurance, workers comp insurance, tools, skills and that they would be provided with a 1099 and would not be an "employee." I do ask them for their scope of work once we have looked at floor plans and actually toured the unit(s). I found that so many of these people had no idea how to go about getting work in a professional way so I helped them iron out the spec sheets. I also very soon realized that a great many people were inundating me in order to satisfy the requirement of the Unemployment Office to "look for work."
Generally, any contractor who walks in and tells you he can put on a new roof (yeah - we had hail damage last year. Who didn't?) and hands me a cerificate of liability insurance probably does NOT STILL have valid insurance, so I have never accepted anyone's copy of that. I just want them to know that when they turn in my bid pack, insurance is required. Thanks for the information regarding this issue, Mark!
When the Recession hit, some areas of the country were hit extremely hard!!!! I think President Obama visited this state at least 3 times when he was campaigning. Property Maintenance is an almost recession-proof industry. But not every one who has painted can actually qualify as a professional Painter. With that being said, for someone who perhaps did used to paint before working for twenty years at the local car plant, I do not see anything wrong with asking him/her for a complimentary example of his/her skillset. I did that early on when I was getting into the design business. I would decorate a room for someone and include that successful design in my portfolio. And, yes, I have asked my mechanic to do something for free. I have been with the same repair shop for years and I have no problem pulling in to his shop with windshield wiper blades and asking him to install them. And he does it with a smile. I am from an itty bitty small town and I grew up with the barter system, so to speak.
I think it was Thomas Jefferson who said, "Every difference of opinion is not a difference of principle." I would not take advantage of anyone. I want to build a lasting relationship with my Vendors. It has worked for me and I have a great cleaning company, carpet cleaning service and carpet stain removal company that all started out providing a "free" service that has now paid handsomly for the both of us for many years. Treating people with respect is a defining principle.
If a contractor is asked to do something for free and they cannot do this because they have been mistreated before, then there is nothing wrong with saying they are willing to paint a unit for whatever you are paying your current provider. I have seem too many contractors do a job half a#@ and NOT fix the problems and demand payment - and that is not worth my time.