I would miss A LOT of great traffic and lose out on Leases if I closed the Office from 4-6PM every week day. My Residents would not be provided with adequate service either. I do not recommend this set up for a conventional property at all and would be pretty upset to learn leasing teams were doing this. For Section 8 properties, I have no problem closing an office from 8-10 AM to the public to complete paperwork, file, return calls to vendors, etc., but I found even those Residents will come to the Office later in the day rather than earlier, so I am not missing them. In addition, for my market communities, I will offer extended hours in the summer, too, to meet leasing demands.
When people show up as you are closing the Office, you simply ask how you can help, and depending on their answer, act accordingly. At times, you need to make a judgment call. I will never forget a Grad Student calling the property at 5:50 PM asking us to stay because he needed to lease something before he went back to his home state. My Assistant point blank said she would NOT stay past our closing time of 6PM and the Leasing person was not there, so I agreed to stay over. When the young man got there and we went through the Showing/Tour and we came back to the Office, he said he would go back home and think about it.
"What????? Are you kidding me," I blurted out. I am sure my face gave every indication I was feeling like strangling him. He took a step back and turned to leave. So I said, "Stephen, I stayed late for you, as you know, to show you this apartment. It's exactly what you are looking for; it's the only one we will have - for heaven's sake, it's 820 square feet 1 bedroom WITH a Garage. Where else are you going to get this? Who else are you considering?"
"You're right," he said.
"You are not going to get a Manager anywhere else in this town who will take care of you and help you like I will. So, you can leave, but I will tell you, this apartment may not be available when you decide next week you want it. Is there something you don't like about it?"
He looked at me a minute. I was all calmed down by that point. "Well, I want to talk to my mom and dad first and I didn't want to commit yet."
From that point on, I told myself his decision would not change my mind. I would still stay over if there was a possibility I could get the lease. I just learned to ask the person asking me to stay over whether or not he was ready to make a decision right then and there. By the way, Stephen called the next morning to reserve the unit and he did end up renting there and stayed the whole three years he was a Grad Student in the MBA program.