My property manager just started a reward board for our team, both leasing and maintenance. Maintenance team members earn points for "no call back" turns on apartments. For leasing, we earn a point for every two apartments leased. For every ten points we earn a $25 gift card.
I think any kind of reward system will be dependent, and effective or ineffective based, on the workings of a team. For me personally ... I'm extremely competitive (have been ever since I was a kid. Ask my dad what it was like playing Shoots and Ladders with me
), so when I see the leasing consultant catching up with me my competitive instinct kicks in and I want to lease more. At the same tie, I know I'm not the best leaser (good call on not making me a leasing consultant, bosses! haha) so it's also in many ways incentive enough when my property manager tells me my most recent closing ratio. I started (in February) with a 17% closing ratio ... I'm up to 77%. About a third of that change I attribute to watching, learning, and stealing techniques from the leasing consultant (she's a super star when it comes to closing on apartments!). About a third is from my own stubborn hatred of having a low score. The last third is just from the manager being SO supportive every time I improved.
I think something as small as a manager coming to the team and saying, "Hey, Property A is at 95% occupancy, but guess what? We're at 96!" can be enough. Or, on the other hand, "Team B is at 96% occupancy at we're at 95 ... Who thinks we can cream their average next month?!" Just little competition like that, where it's friendly "rivalries" (i.e. I joke with the leasing consultant that I think she's shredding leads to bolster her score, so now every time she enters her traffic she shouts across the room at me, "I ENTERED ALL MY TRAFFIC!" and waves her stack at me!), can make a huge difference!